About Awkward Saints

Awkward Saints is an investigative and theological project. It documents concerning dynamics inside church discipleship systems, with particular attention to the Mike Breen / 3DM / Kairos Connexion network and the wider charismatic missional stream that has carried that methodology into charismatic Anglican churches in the UK and beyond.

The project sits at the intersection of three disciplines: investigative work - what is actually happening, in whose words, with what consequences; theological analysis - what claims about Scripture and Christ are being made to license what is happening; and pastoral concern - what those subjected to these dynamics need in order to name them, leave them, or recover from them.

Who writes it

The project is written under the pen name Daniel Caerwyn. The name is a working necessity rather than a literary affectation. The network being documented is small, well-connected, and protective of its leaders. Writing pseudonymously keeps the focus on what is documented here, rather than on who is documenting it.

I write from inside evangelical Anglicanism, not from outside it. I am a member of the Church of England, formed within a high-view-of-Scripture tradition, with no opposition to charismatic ministry, church planting, small communities, or discipleship. The concerns documented here are not anti-discipleship concerns. They are concerns about what specific systems do to the people they form, when those systems claim the authority of Scripture for arrangements Scripture does not warrant.

Why it matters

The dynamics this project examines do not usually produce scandal. They produce something quieter and more durable: communities exhausted by demands they cannot quite articulate, relationships strained by the weight of a leader's expectations, individuals who eventually leave a church without being able to explain to anyone still inside why they had to.

That kind of harm rarely makes the news. It is also the kind that produces the most lasting damage, and the kind that is hardest to name from within the system that produces it. The work of Awkward Saints is to provide language, evidence, and theological framing for those people and concerned observers have often seen but not had the categories to put into words.

What's here

The site holds three kinds of work.

• Investigations. Long-form examinations of specific texts, leaders, and systems. The most recent is a two-part review of Andrew Attwood's Jesus Wants to Train Us to Live His Life, set within the wider 3DM methodology.
• Theological analysis. Essays on the structural moves these systems make: the reclassification of the Gospels as manuals, the flattening of Christology to license human replication of Christ's role, the substitution of human mediators where the cross removed them. These pieces engage N.T. Wright, John Calvin, John Owen, John Wesley, and the historic confessions of the church alongside the texts under examination.
• Mechanism cards. Nine essays examining the specific dynamics that operate inside high-control discipleship systems: Boundary Erosion, Redirected Imitation, Engineered Dependency, Discernment Hijacking, Authority Laundering, Relational Capital Turnstiles, Leadership Bypass, Relational Defence, and Institutional Defence.

For whom

This work is for several kinds of reader. For people who recognise the dynamics and are trying to make sense of what they have lived through. For those still inside a church or network of this kind who are privately uneasy and looking for vocabulary. For pastors, theologians, and concerned Christians watching the spread of these methodologies in their own communions and wanting frameworks for assessment. And for the wider church, in the hope that what gets documented here might inform pastoral practice and theological conversation.

What this is not

This is not a campaign against charismatic Christianity, evangelicalism, discipleship, small groups, or church planting. It is not a personal attack on individuals named in the work; the named figures matter because of the systems they have built and continue to defend, not because of who they are as people.

It is also not exhaustive. The project is one person's reading of a particular set of systems, written from a particular vantage point, and offered for engagement rather than as the final word. I welcome correction, challenge, and theological pushback from anyone willing to engage the substance of what is written here.

Reading and contact

The mailing list is the simplest way to follow new pieces as they go out. Correspondence reaches me at awkwardsaints [at] proton [dot] me.

Daniel Caerwyn